A Good Bear Story

Watch this YouTube video production. It's about a vicious mountain lion attack on a man and a bear that saved his life. It happened here in Butte County fourteen years ago, so it's one of those stories that grew legs. The video was published less a month ago, and it's been viewed 320,000+ times, and 21,000+ viewers liked it.

 

I didn't believe the story. So I surfed the net, and learned that the event took place the last week of March, 2012. A week later at least fourteen media had published the story. Most of them tweaked the title but repeated the original account.

Reporters found Mr Biggs, a self acclaimed "naturist", to be a woodsy story teller. This was the third time he had been attacked by a mountain lion. He had also survived a dangerous fall in the canyon. He told the folks at Animals and our Changing Planet that he was almost 100% sure that the mama bear knew him and wanted to save his life. He had mingled with bears in the past and had high-fived a yearling cub while its mother looked on. 

 NBC news, Paradise Post, and SFGate questioned the story, noting that the Department of Fish and Game was "unable to substantiate the attack". The game warden who interviewed Biggs and looked at his wounds, concluded the injuries were inconsistent with those inflicted by mountain lions. Biggs's confiscated back pack was subjected to forensic analysis and no bear or lion DNA was found. The case was too weak to justify the Department's culling of a mountain lion. 

 Other Doubting Thomases came forth from the blogosphere, including a jolly Aussie (GrahamandFriends) who spoofed the story while donning a happy bear cap. SF Gate's Tom Stienstra reported it "was the biggest hoax pulled off in years - or the wildlife story of the century." 

 To wrap this up, I decided to sample a few YouTube videos about mountain lion and bear encounters. This raised even more questions. I conclude there is no shortage of nature fakers to entertain the gullible. 

News Reports 

https://www.cbsnews.com/sacramento/news/bear-saves-hiker-from-cougar-in-butte-county/ "Man Says Bear Saved Him From Mountain Lion Attack In Butte County" March 29, 2012 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=adi4Pm47Ins, "Man Attacked By Mountain Lion, Saved By Bear" KRCR7 @KRCR7 

https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/man-says-bear-stopped-lion-attack/ "Man Says Bear Stopped Lion Attack, CA man claims mountain lion retreated" March 29, 2012 

https://kdvr.com/news/california-man-says-bear-saved-him-from-mountain-lion-attack/ "California man says bear saved him from mountain lion attack", by Richard J. Ortner, March 31, 2012

https://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2012/03/man-attacked-by-mountain-lion-saved-by-bear "Man Attacked by Mountain Lion, Saved by Bear" By Ashton Marra, March 29, 2012 

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/bear-saves-man-from-mountain-lion_n_1388219 "Bear Saves Robert Biggs From Mountain Lion Attack In California. AWESOME: Man Says Bear Saved Him From Mountain Lion Attack" By Andy Campbell, Mar 29, 2012, Updated Dec 6, 2017 

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/california-officials-mans-claim-bear-saved-him-lion-attack-not-flna605865 "California officials: Man's claim bear saved him from lion attack not substantiated" By U.S. News, March 30, 2012 

 https://www.petersenshunting.com/editorial/bear-saves-hiker-from-mountain-lion-attack/273176 "Bear Saves Hiker from Mountain Lion Attack" By Dylan Polk, April 2, 2012 

 https://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2012/03/man-attacked-by-mountain-lion-saved-by-bear "Man Attacked by Mountain Lion, Saved by Bear" By Ashton Marra, March 29, 2012 

 https://www.9news.com.au/world/bear-saves-man-from-mountain-lion/dda290f1-58c1-4a82-ab47-7f3058db96fc (Sydney, Australia)"Bear saves man from mountain lion" Mar 29, 2012 

 https://fox4kc.com/news/bear-saves-man-from-mountain-lion-attack/ "Bear Saves Man From Mountain Lion Attack" Michelle Pekarsky, Updated: March 30, 2012 

 https://news.yahoo.com/news/blogs/sideshow/man-saved-mountain-lion-bear-says-151626879.html "Man saved from mountain lion by bear, he says. By Dylan Stableford, March 29, 2012 

 https://www.news.com.au/world/bear-saves-california-hiker-from-mountain-lion-attack/news-story/2ca7e0ab37ccc17c646abe6e8d2ac5d4 (Australia) "Bear saves California hiker from mountain lion attack" March 29, 2012 

 https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/man-claims-a-bear-saved-him-from-mountain-lion-attack.1351469/ "Man claims a bear saved him from mountain lion attack" By MacNut, March 31, 2012 (Community Discussion) 

 https://www.sfgate.com/outdoors/article/attacked-by-a-lion-saved-by-a-bear-is-it-true-3450540.php "Attacked by a lion, saved by a bear - is it true?" Tom Stienstra, Outdoors Writer, April 1, 2012 

 https://www.dailymotion.com/video/xpu71l "Bear Saves Man From Mountain Lion!!!" (Video Spoof by GrahamandFriends) 

 https://theworld.org/stories/2016/07/31/robert-biggs-man-attacked-mountain-lion-and-saved-bear-video "Robert Biggs, the man attacked by a mountain lion and saved by a bear (Video)" NewsDesk, July 31, 2016 

 https://www.paradisepost.com/2012/03/29/ridge-man-sticks-by-story-despite-fish-and-game-skepticism/ Ridge man sticks by story, despite Fish and Game skepticism. Paradise Post, By Trevor Warner, Updated May 16, 2018 

Video Productions 

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxtkIzCzdH0 Bear Saves Man from Cougar, Real Facts 

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxtkIzCzdH0, Bear Saves Man from Mountain Lion, THe World@theworld549 (video short in Asian language) 

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_vPKG0KDfaw, Mountain Lion Horribly Mauls Robert Biggs But Then This Bear Arrives, Fierce@Fierce.official 

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZZzllN7jPVI, Bear saves California man from mountain lion attack219, Julienne Buse (animation video) 

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MN0G0urSXZ0, Bear saved Robert Biggs' life while being MAULED alive by Mountain Lion, Wildlife@animalstorytelling (this video refutes Biggs's claims)